Thursday, May 19, 2005 |
15:50 - What movie was he watching?
http://vodkapundit.com/archives/007837.php
|
(top) |
I'm not sure what leads Will Collier to say this (spoilers follow):
Oh, wait, one more thing: the alleged Bush-bashing stuff [in Star Wars: Episode III] has been completely overblown. Trust me on this one. If you get offended by this movie on political grounds, you probably also go into a frothing rage when the car in front of you turns on its left-turn signal. If it weren't for the dumb press coverage, you wouldn't even notice the supposed "controversial" bits.
Oh really? Myself, I dreaded each new Padmé scene for the inevitable Mooreian snarking she'd spout:
"Have you ever considered that we might be on the wrong side?"
"Our democracy has vanished, and it's become the very thing we're trying to destroy!"
"So this is how a democracy dies: to thunderous applause."
And Anakin and Obi-Wan's teeth-gnashing during their duel: "My duty is to the Republic—to democracy!" "I have brought peace... stability... freedom!" And the stuff about how "Palpatine has stayed in office far too long—he has control of the courts, the Senate. He must be removed from office!" Even Obi-Wan's telling Padmé about Anakin's dispatching of the young trainees reads like a Galloway speech, like an accusation of slaughtering Iraqi babies in service of a "lie". I'm not saying this stuff is tangential to the story or doesn't fit—it does—but if it weren't Lucas' intention for everyone to construe this movie as All About Bush, he surely wouldn't have chosen this kind of vocabulary to pepper all over the place, especially when Yoda talks about "a special session of Congress", rather than the Senate. It felt like... like... like a MoveOn.org parody, using Star Wars characters to further their views.
And sure enough, look what just showed up in my mailbox:
Dear MoveOn member,
We've written tens of thousands of letters, made hundreds of thousands of phone calls (20,000 Tuesday alone), and raised a whopping $1.2 million to run ads. Now, as the vote on the nuclear option looms, it's time to break out our secret weapon. We've got to, as the movie says, "use the force."
Today, Star Wars III: Revenge of the Sith opens at theaters nation-wide. And weirdly enough, the plot of what will undoubtedly be one of the biggest films in movie history revolves around a scheming senator who, seduced by visions of absolute power, transforms a democratic republic into an empire.
We've put together a new TV ad, based on the same theme, that we're launching today. It's our first (and only) political ad to feature both a space battle and an army of judge robots. You can check it out at:
http://www.moveonpac.org/savetherepublic/?id=5543-396431-OX0KcMaPfy15F63lJb1p9Q&t=11
The movie's opening buzz and its parallel theme to our current fight for the filibuster present a great opportunity to educate the public — and have some fun. So we've put together a flyer that draws on the Revenge of the Sith story to explain the very real threat to democracy posed by the nuclear option. Any chance you can take half an hour tonight or tomorrow to pass out some of these flyers at your local theater?
They haven't been this giddy about a propaganda blockbuster to endorse since The Day After Tomorrow.
Yet, just like with that movie, their faith in the Blue Side is misplaced—because just as people scoffed at the political stance that such a big stupid blockbuster took (causing more damage to the credibility of global-warming backers than anything else in a decade), if MoveOn.org jumps up and down gesticulating at what cartoon politics Lucas has put in his characters' deadpan dialogue in this movie, people's reaction will be: "What, you're trying to get us to take political lessons from Star Wars?"
Somehow I think the people of high-school age watching this film today will be a tad embarrassed to admit, when they write their college entrance exams or meet up for their first activist group meeting, that they got their indoctrination in a theater filled with people waving toy lightsabers.
But all that aside, outstanding film. A worthy end to the series, and almost enough to wash out the foul taste of Episodes I and II. It had the right sense of scale, the right revelations of things we knew had happened but hadn't seen quite how, and above all it was entertaining—enough so to want to see it again. It even closed out the C-3PO plot loophole—almost as an afterthought, but in a way that worked just fine, though it could have been laughably dumb if handled wrong.
I guess Lucas did know what he was doing... and planned this whole outing this way right from the beginning.
|
|